|
Incredible band, but it would be silly to call them the "best band ever". Firstly, slow any one of their songs down 50%. Sounds suspiciously like Maiden, doesn't it? And don't think Maiden play at the tempo they do because they can't play faster. It's because they balance speed and feeling.
Also, their lyrics make less and less sense with each album. And don't argue, because ZP himself said that they are just there for atmosphere and the melodies. That's lazy, in my opinion. It's fun for a while, but you can't just write entire albums based on Power Metal cliches. There need to be stories, not a whole bunch of arbitrary images.
Awesome guitar work, awesome singing (especially on IR), great drumming, fantastic energy, catchy melodies and speeeeeed, but there's not enough variety and originality. Also, they've only got 3 albums under their belt. Let's talk again in a couple of years.
PS. there are many guitarists better that Sam and Herman (especially Sam, though he is great). Vai and Michael Romeo
are good examples. You need accuracy, feeling and variation as well as speed. Also, a lot of it is tremolo picking and simple tapping (okay, mostly Sam. Herman's pretty bulletproof). They're awesome, but it'll be some time before they reach Vai level.
I'd say they're top ten, at the moment.
|